Voltesta

Gear world: pull or speed, not the most of both

Put a 2 kW motor on a 3D rig and tilt the ramp. Choose a hub motor or a mid motor with a belt, change the gear ratio, the wheel size and the load, and see pull, top speed and hill-climbing change.

How this lab works

  1. Watch the motor and the wheel

    The rig starts with a mid motor and an 8 to 1 belt. The small pulley on the motor turns eight times for each turn of the wheel. The turning is slowed down so you can follow it.

  2. Change the ratio and the wheel

    Move the gear ratio and pick another wheel. The green curve on the chart is the push at the tyre. A bigger ratio lifts the left end of the curve and pulls the right end in.

  3. Load it and tilt the ramp

    Add load and slope. The brown curve is what holds the vehicle back. Where the two curves cross is the speed it settles at. If the green curve starts below the brown one, it cannot move.

Run the rig

Drag to look around. Use + and − to zoom.

The drive
The job
0Speed (km/h)
0Motor speed (rpm)
0Wheel speed (rpm)
0Torque at the wheel (Nm)
0Push at the tyre (N)
0Holding it back (N)

What this set-up can do

0Push from rest (N)
0Steepest slope it can start on (%)
0Top speed on this slope (km/h):
–0 to 40 km/h on the flat (s)

Push at the tyre against road speed

Push at the tyreHolding it backCurve you keptWhere it is now

Reading the picture

  • The yellow spoke on each wheel and the marks on the pulleys show how fast each part turns.
  • The yellow dot on the chart is where the vehicle is now.
  • The crate grows with the load.

Things to try

  1. Mid motor: move the ratio from 3 to 8 to 12

    The pull from rest goes from about 250 N to 650 N to 980 N. Top speed stays near 56 km/h until 12 to 1, where the motor runs out of revs at 47 km/h.

  2. 400 kg load on a 10% slope: try the hub motor, then the mid motor at 3 and at 8

    The hub motor and the 3 to 1 mid motor cannot move the load. At 8 to 1 the same 2 kW climbs at about 12 km/h. This is why loaded three-wheelers use a reduction gear.

  3. Hub motor: small wheel, then large wheel

    A hub motor has no gear, so the wheel is its gearing. The small wheel gives 475 N and starts on a 26% slope; the large wheel gives 317 N and manages 17%.

  4. Press Keep this curve, then change one thing

    The old curve stays as a grey dashed line. The flat part moves up or down with the ratio, but the falling part always lies on the same line, because that part is set by the motor's power.

  5. Compare the hub motor with the mid motor at 5 to 1

    They pull almost the same. A hub motor is a slow, strong motor; a mid motor is a small, fast one with the strength added by the gear.

How the simulation works

Both motors give 2 kW. The hub motor makes up to 95 Nm and turns up to 700 rpm, and it drives the wheel directly. The mid motor makes up to 22 Nm and turns up to 6,000 rpm, and drives the wheel through a reduction that loses 7%. Each gives its full torque from rest and holds 2 kW once it is turning fast enough.

Push at the tyre is motor torque times the gear ratio, divided by the wheel radius. Road speed is motor speed divided by the ratio, times the wheel radius. So the ratio trades one for the other, and a bigger wheel does the reverse of a bigger ratio.

What holds the vehicle back is tyre drag, air drag and the slope, worked out as in the ride world. The vehicle speeds up while the push is greater and settles where the two are equal. Top speed is set either by power, where the curves cross, or by the motor reaching its top revs.

The figures are typical for a small scooter and are meant to show the pattern. The model leaves out tyre slip, motor heating and battery limits.

Every value here comes from a teaching model running in your browser, with typical figures. They are not measurements from real hardware.